Not-for-profits
Writing an Investment Policy Statement That Actually Guides Decisions
. Tilbrook Investment Team. 4 min read

An investment policy statement should be a working document, not a compliance artefact. Here is how not-for-profit boards can write one that brings clarity in calm markets and discipline in turbulent ones.
Almost every not-for-profit that holds investments has an investment policy statement. Far fewer have one that genuinely shapes decisions. In many organisations the document was drafted years ago, perhaps adapted from a template, and is reviewed mainly to confirm that nothing needs to change.
A well-written investment policy statement does much more than satisfy governance expectations. It translates the organisation's mission and financial realities into clear investment principles. It gives committee members a shared reference point, helps new members get up to speed, and provides an anchor when markets are volatile and the temptation to react is strong.
Start with purpose, not portfolios
The most common weakness in investment policy statements is that they begin with asset allocation. The better starting point is the purpose of the money. Different pools of capital serve different roles, and a single policy that treats them all identically can create tension.
Before discussing investments at all, the board should be able to answer some fundamental questions:
- What are these funds for? Operating reserves, a capital works program, a perpetual endowment, or a combination?
- Over what time horizon will the funds be needed?
- Are any funds subject to donor restrictions or conditions about how they may be invested or spent?
- What would be the practical consequence for the organisation if the portfolio fell significantly in value over a short period?
- How much of the organisation's annual budget depends on investment income or distributions?
Where an organisation holds funds with clearly different purposes, it is often sensible to describe them as separate pools within the policy, each with its own objectives and risk settings.
The essential components
While each policy should reflect its organisation, most effective statements address a consistent set of elements.
- Objectives: what the portfolio is intended to achieve, expressed in terms meaningful to the organisation, such as preserving purchasing power or funding a defined level of annual support.
- Risk tolerance: how much variability in value the organisation can accept, described in practical terms the board understands.
- Liquidity requirements: how much must be readily accessible, and how quickly.
- Strategic asset allocation: target weightings and permitted ranges for each asset class.
- Rebalancing approach: when and how the portfolio is brought back towards its targets.
- Responsible investment parameters: any exclusions, preferences or engagement expectations that reflect the organisation's values.
- Roles and responsibilities: who does what, across the board, committee, management and external providers.
- Monitoring and review: how performance and compliance are reported and how often the policy itself is reviewed.
Write objectives that can be tested
Vague objectives such as achieving strong returns while managing risk are of little practical use. They cannot be measured, and they do not help the committee choose between alternatives. Better objectives connect directly to what the organisation needs.
For a long-term endowment, an objective might be framed around maintaining the real value of capital after distributions and costs over rolling multi-year periods. For an operating reserve, the emphasis may instead be on capital stability and ready access. The point is that a reader should be able to look at the objective and know whether, over the appropriate horizon, it has been met.
The point is that a reader should be able to look at the objective and know whether, over the appropriate horizon, it has been met.
Describe risk in language the board understands
Technical measures of risk have their place, but a policy that relies on them alone may not be well understood by every board member. Many committees find it helpful to supplement statistical measures with plain-language descriptions of what different outcomes would mean in practice.
For example, the committee might discuss what a substantial decline in portfolio value would mean for programs, staffing or grant commitments, and whether the organisation could tolerate that outcome without being forced to sell assets at an inopportune time. This kind of conversation produces a risk tolerance that the board has genuinely agreed to, rather than one it has simply accepted.
Plan for the hard moments
An investment policy statement proves its worth when markets are falling. That is when committees come under the greatest pressure to depart from their agreed approach. A policy that anticipates these moments can be enormously valuable.
- Set out the rebalancing discipline clearly, including whether rebalancing continues during market stress.
- Agree in advance on any circumstances in which the committee would consider changing strategy, and the process for doing so.
- Clarify how distributions or spending will be managed if the portfolio falls in value.
- Ensure liquidity provisions are sufficient to meet obligations without forced selling.
Decisions made calmly, in advance, tend to be better than decisions made in the middle of a downturn.
Keep it alive
A policy should be concise enough to be read and referred to. Many effective statements run to only a handful of pages, with supporting detail placed in schedules that can be updated without revisiting the whole document.
It should also be reviewed on a regular cycle and whenever the organisation's circumstances change materially, such as after a major bequest, a strategic shift or a change in funding model. Review should be a genuine exercise, testing whether objectives, risk settings and liquidity provisions still reflect reality, rather than a formality.
Finally, the policy should be part of every new committee member's induction. A document that every member has read and understands is a far stronger foundation for good decisions than one that only the chair could locate on request.
Organisations reviewing their policy may wish to consider relevant guidance from the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission on governance and financial management, and to seek independent advice suited to their particular structure and obligations.
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).
Latest insights

Family office
The Family Office Model: When It Makes Sense, and the Alternatives
A family office can bring coordination, control and continuity to complex family wealth, but it is not the only path. We explain what family offices do, when they make sense and what alternatives exist.
, 4 min read

Investment strategy
Investing for Perpetuity: The Principles of Endowment-Style Investing for Families and Foundations
Endowment-style investing is built on a simple premise: capital that is meant to last for generations should be managed differently. We outline the principles and how families and foundations can apply them.
, 4 min read

Responsible investing
Impact Investing: Measuring What Matters
Impact investing promises measurable social and environmental outcomes alongside financial returns. Understanding how impact is defined, measured and reported is essential to making that promise meaningful.
, 4 min read