Not-for-profits
Is Your Investment Committee Really Working? A Self-Assessment for Not-for-Profit Boards
. Tilbrook Advice Team. 4 min read

Most investment committees meet regularly, receive reports and approve recommendations. Fewer stop to ask whether they are genuinely adding value. A structured self-assessment can help.
For many not-for-profit organisations, the investment committee is one of the quieter parts of the governance structure. It meets on a regular cycle, receives a report from its adviser or manager, notes the performance numbers and moves on. Nothing appears to be wrong, and so nobody asks whether anything could be better.
Yet the committee carries real responsibility. The reserves and investments it oversees often underpin an organisation's ability to deliver its mission through difficult years, honour long-term commitments to donors and beneficiaries, and plan with confidence. A committee that is merely functioning is not the same as a committee that is working well. The difference usually only becomes obvious under pressure, which is precisely the wrong time to discover it.
This article offers a practical self-assessment framework. It is not a scorecard to be passed or failed, but a set of prompts designed to start an honest conversation among committee members and the broader board.
Clarity of purpose and authority
An effective committee knows exactly what it is responsible for and what it is not. That sounds obvious, but in practice many committees operate on inherited assumptions rather than a clear, current mandate from the board.
- Does the committee have a written charter or terms of reference, and has it been reviewed in the last two to three years?
- Is it clear which decisions the committee can make on its own and which must be referred to the full board?
- Do committee members understand how the investment portfolio connects to the organisation's strategic plan and operating budget?
- Is there a shared understanding of what the funds are for, such as operating reserves, capital projects, endowment or bequest capital?
Where the answers are uncertain, the most useful first step is often simply to write things down. A short, plain-language charter removes ambiguity and gives new members something concrete to work from.
Composition, skills and independence
Committees are frequently built from whoever on the board has a finance background, supplemented by a volunteer or two from the wider community. That can work well, but it can also produce a group with overlapping skills and some notable gaps.
- Does the committee collectively hold the skills it needs, including investment knowledge, financial oversight, legal or governance experience and a strong understanding of the mission?
- Are there clear processes for identifying and managing conflicts of interest, including where members have professional relationships with service providers?
- Is there a planned approach to succession so that knowledge is not lost when long-serving members step down?
- Do members feel able to question the adviser, the chair and each other without discomfort?
A committee that is merely functioning is not the same as a committee that is working well.
Diversity of perspective matters here as much as technical expertise. A committee where everyone has the same professional background may reach agreement quickly, but quick agreement is not always good judgement.
Policy and decision-making discipline
The investment policy statement is the committee's central tool. It should articulate objectives, risk tolerance, liquidity needs, asset allocation ranges and any ethical or responsible investment parameters. Its real value, however, lies in how it is used.
- Is the investment policy statement referred to in meetings, or does it sit in a folder until its scheduled review?
- When the committee makes a decision, is it recorded alongside the reasoning, so that a future committee can understand why?
- Has the committee agreed in advance how it will respond to a significant market decline, rather than leaving that to be worked out in the moment?
- Are departures from policy treated as exceptions requiring explicit justification?
Good process is particularly valuable during periods of market stress. Committees that have agreed their principles beforehand are far better placed to avoid reactive decisions that may later be regretted.
Meetings, reporting and the use of time
One of the most revealing questions a committee can ask is how it spends its meeting time. If the majority of each meeting is devoted to reviewing recent returns, there may be little left for the strategic questions that genuinely benefit from the committee's attention.
- Do meeting papers arrive early enough for members to read and reflect on them?
- Is reporting framed against the organisation's own objectives and policy, rather than only against market indices?
- Does each meeting include time for forward-looking discussion, such as changes in the organisation's needs, emerging risks or policy refinements?
- Are agenda items prioritised so that important issues are not crowded out by routine updates?
A simple annual work plan can help. By scheduling deeper topics across the year, such as a liquidity review one quarter and a responsible investment discussion the next, the committee ensures that strategic matters receive deliberate attention.
Oversight of advisers and providers
Most committees rely on external advisers, investment managers and custodians. Oversight of these relationships is a core part of the committee's role, and one that can drift over time as familiarity grows.
- Does the committee understand the full cost of its investment arrangements, including advice, management and administration fees?
- Are adviser and manager arrangements reviewed periodically against clear criteria?
- Is the committee confident it understands the advice it receives, and does it feel comfortable asking for plainer explanations?
- Are responsibilities between the committee, management and external providers clearly documented?
Turning reflection into action
A self-assessment is only useful if it leads somewhere. Many committees find it helpful for each member to complete the questions independently before discussing the results together. Differences in responses are often more informative than the answers themselves, because they reveal where assumptions are not shared.
From there, the committee can agree on a small number of practical improvements, assign responsibility and revisit progress at a set date. Some organisations repeat the exercise annually; others combine it with a broader board evaluation. Either way, the aim is the same: a committee that is clear about its purpose, equipped to fulfil it and disciplined in how it does so.
Boards seeking further guidance on governance standards for charities may find the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission's governance resources a useful starting point, alongside independent advice tailored to their organisation's circumstances.
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).
Latest insights

Family office
The Family Office Model: When It Makes Sense, and the Alternatives
A family office can bring coordination, control and continuity to complex family wealth, but it is not the only path. We explain what family offices do, when they make sense and what alternatives exist.
, 4 min read

Investment strategy
Investing for Perpetuity: The Principles of Endowment-Style Investing for Families and Foundations
Endowment-style investing is built on a simple premise: capital that is meant to last for generations should be managed differently. We outline the principles and how families and foundations can apply them.
, 4 min read

Responsible investing
Impact Investing: Measuring What Matters
Impact investing promises measurable social and environmental outcomes alongside financial returns. Understanding how impact is defined, measured and reported is essential to making that promise meaningful.
, 4 min read