Skip to content

Retirement & super

The first decade of retirement: why the order of returns matters

. Tilbrook Advice Team. 3 min read

Two retirees can earn the same average return and end up in very different places. Sequencing risk explains why, and why the early years of retirement deserve particular care.

For most of a working life, a market fall is an inconvenience. Contributions keep flowing in, and lower prices simply mean each dollar buys a little more. Retirement changes that arithmetic. Once you begin drawing an income from your savings, the timing of good and bad years starts to matter as much as the average.

This is what planners call sequencing risk: the risk that poor returns arrive early in retirement, just as withdrawals begin. It is one of the least intuitive ideas in personal finance, and one of the most important to understand before you stop work.

Same average, different outcome

Imagine two retirees with identical balances who withdraw the same amount each year and experience exactly the same set of annual returns over twenty years, only in reverse order. One meets the weak years first; the other meets them last.

On paper their average return is identical. In practice, the retiree who meets the downturn early is selling assets at depressed prices to fund living costs. Those units are gone and cannot participate in the recovery. The retiree who meets the downturn late has already enjoyed years of growth on a larger base, and the same fall does far less lasting damage.

Once you begin drawing an income from your savings, the timing of good and bad years starts to matter as much as the average.

Why the first ten years carry the most weight

The years either side of retirement are often when a portfolio is at its largest, so a given percentage fall represents the greatest dollar loss. At the same time, withdrawals are just starting, and there is a long horizon ahead that the money must cover. A shortfall created early has many years to compound.

That is why sequencing risk is usually discussed as a transition-to-retirement issue rather than a lifelong one. By the later stages of retirement, the balance is typically smaller and the remaining horizon shorter, so the order of returns tends to matter less.

Approaches families commonly consider

There is no single fix, and every approach involves trade-offs between security, flexibility and long-term growth. Some of the ideas people explore with their advisers include:

  • Holding a cash or short-term reserve to fund a period of living costs, so growth assets are not sold during a downturn.
  • Reviewing the mix of growth and defensive assets in the years leading up to and just after retirement.
  • Building some flexibility into spending, so discretionary items can be deferred in a weak year.
  • Considering whether part of retirement income could come from more predictable sources.
  • Coordinating the timing of retirement, part-time work or the sale of other assets with the overall plan.

Each of these has costs. A large cash reserve can drag on long-term returns. A more defensive portfolio may need to last longer than expected. The right balance depends on your circumstances, other income, health, family commitments and how comfortable you are with variability.

Planning before the transition

Sequencing risk is easiest to manage when it is considered well before the final working day. Superannuation rules, pension drawdown requirements and access conditions also shape what is possible, and these change over time, so it is worth confirming the current position with your adviser or the ATO.

The goal is not to predict markets, which no one can do reliably. It is to arrange your affairs so that a poor run of early years is uncomfortable rather than decisive, and your retirement plan can absorb it.

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).

Latest news

Firm news

Introducing The Tilbrook Brief

The Tilbrook Brief is our new periodic newsletter, bringing together our insights on wealth, family and giving. Subscribe through the Newsletter page on our website.

, 2 min read

Markets & outlook

The year ahead: six themes we are watching in 2027

Rather than forecasts, we offer a set of themes likely to shape conversations about wealth in 2027, from the path of inflation to private markets, technology and the transfer of wealth between generations.

, 2 min read

Firm news

Our home in Brisbane: 80 Petrie Terrace

Our office at 80 Petrie Terrace in Brisbane City is the base from which we serve clients across Queensland and around Australia, in person or online.

, 2 min read