Investment strategy
Through an Endowment Lens: Spending Rules and Intergenerational Equity
. Tilbrook Investment Team. 4 min read

How much can a long-term portfolio sustainably distribute? We explore how spending rules shape portfolio construction and help families and foundations treat present and future beneficiaries fairly.
For any pool of capital intended to last for generations, one question sits beneath every investment decision: how much can we responsibly take out each year? The answer shapes almost everything else, from the level of risk the portfolio must accept to the mix of assets it holds and the liquidity it needs.
Endowment-style investors approach this question through the lens of intergenerational equity, the idea that the capital should treat today's beneficiaries and tomorrow's fairly. This article looks at how spending rules work, the trade-offs involved, and how they connect to portfolio construction for families and foundations.
Why spending policy comes first
It is tempting to begin with the portfolio and treat spending as whatever the portfolio can support. Long-term investors tend to reverse that logic. They first decide what level and pattern of spending they want to sustain, then design a portfolio with a reasonable prospect of supporting it while preserving real value.
The logic is straightforward. If a foundation intends to distribute a certain proportion of its capital each year, and also to maintain its purchasing power indefinitely, then over the long run its portfolio needs to earn at least that distribution rate plus inflation plus costs. That required return in turn implies a certain level of investment risk. Spending policy and investment policy are two sides of the same decision.
Spending policy and investment policy are two sides of the same decision.
Common approaches to spending rules
There is no single correct spending rule. Each approach balances stability of distributions against responsiveness to portfolio value in a different way.
- Income only: distributing the interest, dividends and rent the portfolio generates. Simple, but it can bias the portfolio towards high-yielding assets and produces distributions that bear little relation to total value.
- Fixed percentage of current value: spending a set proportion of the portfolio each year. Responsive and self-correcting, but distributions can fluctuate sharply with markets.
- Smoothed percentage: applying a target rate to an average of portfolio values over several years. This dampens volatility in distributions while still adjusting over time.
- Inflation-linked: increasing the previous year's distribution by inflation, often within upper and lower bounds tied to portfolio value. This prioritises predictability for beneficiaries.
- Hybrid rules: blending an inflation-adjusted amount with a percentage of current value, aiming to capture the benefits of both.
Smoothed and hybrid rules are widely used because they tend to offer beneficiaries a degree of predictability while still allowing spending to adjust gradually if the portfolio's value changes materially.
The Australian context
For Australian foundations, spending rules do not operate in a vacuum. Private ancillary funds and public ancillary funds are subject to minimum annual distribution requirements, and other charitable trusts may have obligations set by their trust deeds or by law. These requirements are determined by legislation and guidelines that are periodically reviewed, so trustees should always refer to current ATO guidance rather than relying on figures from previous years.
A well-designed spending rule should comfortably satisfy any applicable minimum while reflecting the foundation's own objectives. Where the foundation intends to distribute more than the minimum, or to vary its giving deliberately over time, the rule should make that explicit.
Families managing legacy capital through trusts or companies face different considerations, including tax treatment of distributions, the needs of different family branches and the terms of any governing documents. The principle, however, is the same: a clear, agreed approach to distributions provides a foundation for sound investment decisions.
Building the portfolio around the rule
Once a spending policy is agreed, it informs portfolio construction in several practical ways.
- Return requirement: the spending rate, plus inflation and costs, indicates the long-term return the portfolio needs to target to preserve real value.
- Growth orientation: a perpetual pool seeking to maintain purchasing power will typically need a meaningful allocation to growth assets.
- Liquidity buffer: holding enough in cash and liquid defensive assets to fund several years of distributions can help avoid selling growth assets during a downturn.
- Illiquid allocations: the predictability of spending determines how much capital can sensibly be committed to investments that cannot be readily sold.
- Rebalancing: the spending rule and rebalancing policy should work together, so that distributions are drawn in a way that supports the target allocation.
Weighing the trade-offs
Every spending rule involves trade-offs, and trustees should make them consciously. A higher spending rate delivers more support now but requires either a higher-risk portfolio or acceptance that real value may erode. A lower rate preserves capital more reliably but may leave present needs unmet.
Stability is a value in itself. For a foundation supporting multi-year grants, or a family relying on distributions for education or living costs, sharp swings in spending can be disruptive. Smoothing provides predictability but means spending will lag behind changes in portfolio value, both upwards and downwards.
There are also questions of mission timing. Some foundations deliberately choose to spend more heavily during a particular period because they believe the need is greatest now. Others commit to a defined life span. These are legitimate choices, but they should be made explicitly rather than arising by default.
Putting it into practice
Families and foundations reviewing their spending approach might consider the following steps:
- Articulate the time horizon and purpose of the capital: perpetual, defined life, or flexible.
- Identify any legal, regulatory or trust-deed requirements that set minimum or maximum distributions.
- Agree on the relative importance of predictability for beneficiaries versus responsiveness to market value.
- Select a spending rule and document it within the investment policy statement.
- Test the rule against a range of market scenarios to understand how distributions and capital might behave.
- Review the rule periodically, and whenever circumstances or objectives change.
A clear spending rule does not eliminate difficult decisions, but it does provide a principled framework for making them. Above all, it allows trustees to answer, with confidence, the question that matters most for any long-lived pool of capital: are we being fair to both the present and the future?
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).
Latest insights

Family office
The Family Office Model: When It Makes Sense, and the Alternatives
A family office can bring coordination, control and continuity to complex family wealth, but it is not the only path. We explain what family offices do, when they make sense and what alternatives exist.
, 4 min read

Investment strategy
Investing for Perpetuity: The Principles of Endowment-Style Investing for Families and Foundations
Endowment-style investing is built on a simple premise: capital that is meant to last for generations should be managed differently. We outline the principles and how families and foundations can apply them.
, 4 min read

Responsible investing
Impact Investing: Measuring What Matters
Impact investing promises measurable social and environmental outcomes alongside financial returns. Understanding how impact is defined, measured and reported is essential to making that promise meaningful.
, 4 min read