Skip to content

Philanthropy

Giving Well: Avoiding the Common Mistakes in Philanthropy

. Tilbrook Philanthropy Team. 4 min read

Good intentions are the starting point of philanthropy, not the whole of it. We look at the most common pitfalls givers encounter and the practical habits that help generosity go further.

Philanthropy is one of the most personal uses of wealth. It reflects what people value, what they hope to change and the legacy they wish to leave. Because it is so personal, it is also easy to approach intuitively rather than strategically. Generosity is always worthwhile, but some patterns of giving consistently achieve less than donors intend.

Drawing on common experiences across the sector, this article outlines frequent mistakes and the habits that can help givers avoid them. None of these are failings of character. They are simply the natural consequences of giving without a framework, and most are easily addressed.

Mistake one: spreading too thinly

Many donors support a long list of organisations with relatively small amounts each. This can feel fair and responsive, especially when requests arrive from friends, colleagues and community groups. The difficulty is that small, scattered gifts can be costly for charities to process and report on, and they make it hard for the donor to understand whether their giving is making a difference.

Concentrating a larger share of giving on a few areas of genuine interest allows a donor to build knowledge, develop deeper relationships and see the effects of their support more clearly. Many givers retain a smaller, separate allocation for responsive or community giving so they can still say yes to personal requests.

Mistake two: over-restricting gifts

Donors understandably want to know where their money goes, and project-specific funding offers that reassurance. However, heavily restricted funding can leave organisations struggling to cover the essential costs that make programs possible: skilled staff, systems, financial management and leadership.

Where a donor has confidence in an organisation's leadership and strategy, unrestricted or flexible funding can often be more valuable than a tightly defined grant. It allows the organisation to direct resources where they are most needed and to respond to change. Trust, built through due diligence and relationships, is what makes this possible.

Where a donor has confidence in an organisation's leadership and strategy, unrestricted or flexible funding can often be more valuable than a tightly defined grant.

Mistake three: judging charities mainly by overheads

It is common to assess charities by the proportion of their spending that goes to administration. While efficiency matters, a low overhead figure is not a reliable indicator of effectiveness. An organisation that underinvests in its people, systems and evaluation may struggle to deliver quality programs or to know whether those programs are working.

A more useful set of questions focuses on outcomes and capability:

  • Does the organisation have a clear theory of how its work creates change?
  • How does it measure and learn from its results?
  • Is its leadership capable, and is its governance sound?
  • Is it financially sustainable, with reasonable reserves and diverse funding?
  • How does it involve the communities it serves in shaping its work?

Information on registered charities, including annual reporting, is available through the ACNC Charity Register and can be a helpful starting point.

Mistake four: short-term commitments to long-term problems

Many of the issues philanthropists care about most, such as educational disadvantage, health inequity or environmental degradation, take years to shift. Yet a great deal of philanthropic funding is offered one year at a time, leaving organisations uncertain about the future and spending significant effort on repeated applications.

Multi-year commitments, where a donor is able to make them, give organisations the stability to plan, recruit and invest. They also signal a partnership rather than a transaction. Donors can still build in sensible review points, with continued funding subject to agreed conditions.

Mistake five: imposing rather than listening

Donors often bring valuable expertise from business or professional life, and that experience can be a genuine asset. But it can also lead to a tendency to prescribe solutions to organisations and communities that understand their own circumstances more deeply.

The most effective philanthropic relationships tend to be built on humility and listening. Asking what an organisation needs, rather than assuming, and respecting the knowledge of those closest to an issue, leads to better decisions and stronger partnerships.

Mistake six: neglecting structure, governance and succession

Givers who establish formal structures, such as private ancillary funds, sometimes focus on the excitement of setting up and underestimate the ongoing obligations. Trustees must meet distribution, reporting and investment requirements set by regulation, and these can change over time. Keeping across current ATO and ACNC guidance is part of the responsibility.

Succession is another area that is easily overlooked. Without a plan for who will continue the work, and how decisions will be made when founders are no longer involved, even a well-established foundation can lose its way.

Taken together, avoiding these mistakes does not require a large team or a complex strategy. A few consistent habits go a long way:

  • Write down your purpose and focus areas, and refer to them when making decisions.
  • Plan your giving budget in advance rather than responding entirely to requests.
  • Conduct proportionate due diligence, then extend trust to organisations you believe in.
  • Consider flexible and multi-year funding where it fits your circumstances.
  • Build relationships and listen to the organisations and communities you support.
  • Reflect regularly on what you have learned, and adjust your approach accordingly.
  • Plan for the governance and succession of any giving structure you establish.

Giving well is not about perfection. It is about bringing the same care and thought to philanthropy that you would bring to any other important decision. The reward is giving that is not only generous, but genuinely effective.

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).

Latest insights

Responsible investing

Impact Investing: Measuring What Matters

Impact investing promises measurable social and environmental outcomes alongside financial returns. Understanding how impact is defined, measured and reported is essential to making that promise meaningful.

, 4 min read